The quest points strongly toward Reverend Nathaniel Pastodi, but the investigation has an important second lead. If you rush the confrontation, the game can finish without revealing the actual culprit. Ask questions first to uncover the clue involving formaldehyde.
At Crippled Kate’s, choose “Got a few questions for you first” and then ask about the formaldehyde clue. The conversation redirects the investigation toward coroner Hubert Rejk and unlocks the follow-up warehouse encounter.
Find your next step
Carnal Sins: choose what to do at Crippled Kate’s
One short conversation protects the investigation. A rushed confrontation can end the trail too soon.
Do it in this order
Progress Cabaret and Carnal Sins
Follow the initial leads from the hospital, medical examination and witness interviews in Novigrad.
Reach Crippled Kate’s
The quest points you toward Nathaniel. Do not immediately finish the confrontation.
Choose the questioning dialogue
Select “Got a few questions for you first” to preserve further investigation.
Ask about formaldehyde
Use the specific clue from the earlier examination to reveal the inconsistency in the case.
Follow the Hubert Rejk lead
Continue to the warehouse objective and complete the investigation before closing the quest.
Frequently asked questions
Is Nathaniel the real killer?
He is a suspect, but questioning him reveals evidence pointing to the coroner, Hubert Rejk.
What dialogue should I choose first?
Choose “Got a few questions for you first” before taking any action that could end the encounter.
Why ask about formaldehyde?
That earlier clue is what exposes the contradiction and opens the continuation of the investigation.
Can I return if I rushed the scene?
Usually the most reliable solution is to reload a save from before the confrontation.
Sources & further reading
WalkerBex is an independent fan resource. Versions, quest states, New Game+ and localization may change names, levels or rewards. Images are original artistic illustrations, not in-game screenshots.